De lerende mens

Op zoek naar onderwijs dat mensen vormt

Menu
  • Over/About
  • Blogposts
  • Blogposts in het Nederlands
  • Blogposts in English
  • Theology and Science on the Evolution of Religion
Menu

M. Ruse, called an ‘Anti-Catholic Atheist’, to Deliver Diatribe on Evolution at Jesuit’s LeMoyne College – Aleteia

Geplaatst op oktober 15, 2013 door tomuytt

See on Scoop.it – Cultural evolution

Anti-Catholic Atheist to Deliver Diatribe on Evolution at Jesuit’s LeMoyne College
Aleteia
Michael Ruse, PhD., who calls himself a non-believer, will be speaking at the Jesuit college on Thursday, Oct.

Tom Uytterhoeven’s insight:

There are two things that I do not like about this message. First, there is the aggressive tone. There is the troll figure, shouting out a straw man version of evolutionary theory. Ruse is not only called an atheist, but an ‘anti-catholic’ atheist – which apparently is assumed to be the worst kind – because he criticised a number of features within the Roman Catholic Church – some of which are also criticised by a number of Catholics themselves, btw – and criticised a statement made by pope emeritus Benedict XVI – which actually is allowed by canonical law; not every word a pope says automatically becomes infallible. All in all, the article clearly wants to make the case that something bad is happening at LeMoyne College: someone is going to talk about evolutionary theory. 

Never mind that the Catholic Church holds that (evolutionary) science and faith should not be seen as contradicting each other (even Wiki knows this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Church_and_evolution#Catholic_teaching_and_evolution): the author of the Aleteia blogpost knows better than that: evolution is wrong… So I guess the works of catholic theologians like e.g. John Haught or even Karl Rahner should be put on the index?

Although I have no affiliation with mentioned College, as a Catholic theologian I’m worried about articles like this, claiming science is in opposition with faith and that we should abandon science to keep faith pure and sound. I believe this attitude is non-Catholic, maybe even anti-Catholic, because it will diminish our ability to act on God’s revelation, to act on His call to do good in this world. not to mention that this attitude brings us back to the days of Galileo, from which John Paul II decisively distanced the Roman Catholic Church.

 

This is not to say that I agree with everything Ruse claims. I think his interpretation on the Huffington Post blog of Benedict’s speech on evolution could be discussed and refined, and that he certainly goes too fast in equating what a pope or a cardinal says with ’the’ theology of the Roman Catholic Theology. I think the latter is as wrong, reductionist and simplifying as equating e.g. Stephen Gould’s work with ’the’ evolutionary science: there is more diversity and more debate going on than meets the superficial eye… But that brings me to the second reason to dislike the Aleteia piece: since when does (Catholic) education entail listening only to what you already agree with, to close yourself off from those impulses that bring up questions and make you think things through more thorough? In his book "Introduction to Christianity" (http://www.ignatius.com/Products/INCH2-P/introduction-to-christianity-2nd-edition.aspx), cardinal Ratzinger (yes, the same person Aleteia refers to) warns for the danger of Christian faith becoming marginalized. He uses the loaded term "ghetto" to bring this danger to the fore very sharp and clear. I think that’s precisely what things like this Aleteia-rant lead us to. 

See on www.aleteia.org

Dit delen:

  • Delen op Facebook (Wordt in een nieuw venster geopend) Facebook
  • Delen op X (Wordt in een nieuw venster geopend) X
  • Delen op Reddit (Wordt in een nieuw venster geopend) Reddit
  • Delen op Tumblr (Wordt in een nieuw venster geopend) Tumblr
  • Email a link to a friend (Wordt in een nieuw venster geopend) E-mail
  • Afdrukken (Wordt in een nieuw venster geopend) Print
  • Meer
  • Deel op LinkedIn (Wordt in een nieuw venster geopend) LinkedIn
  • Deel op WhatsApp (Wordt in een nieuw venster geopend) WhatsApp
  • Delen op Mastodon (Wordt in een nieuw venster geopend) Mastodon
  • Delen op Bluesky (Wordt in een nieuw venster geopend) Bluesky

Vind ik leuk:

Like Bezig met laden...

Gerelateerd

Berichtnavigatie

← This Apple Commercial Sums Up Everything That’s Wrong With Our Screen-Addicted Culture
How to Ride the Coattails of an Existing Meme – Multichannel Merchant →

Een reactie achterlaten Reactie annuleren

Je e-mailadres zal niet getoond worden. Vereiste velden zijn gemarkeerd met *

Deze website gebruikt Akismet om spam te verminderen. Bekijk hoe je reactie gegevens worden verwerkt.

Contact

  • Email
  • Linkedin
  • Bluesky

Search

  • Blogpost
  • Blogposts in English
  • Blogposts in het Nederlands

Anthropology art atheism big history burgerschap cartoon citaat conference creation cultural evolution Culture cultuur Darwin Dennett Diversity education elisabeth johnson environment evolutie evolution Evolutionary Psychology faith fundamentalism geloof God Hefner katholieke dialoogschool Language meaning Memes nature onderwijs Philip Hefner pluralism Psychology religie religion religion and science science science and religion technology theology wetenschap wetenschap en theologie writing

Privacy en cookies: deze website gebruikt van cookies. Door verder te gaan op deze website, ga je akkoord met het gebruik hiervan.
Voor meer informatie, onder andere over cookiebeheer, bekijk je: Cookiebeleid
©2026 De lerende mens
%d